Hello,
Here is my scenario. Clients A and B can succesfully be cloned from a server running udp-sender when connected together via a hub. Either one can also be successfully cloned as the only client to the server when connected on the switch (as I understand it, this scenario is actually unicast, not multicast). When attemping to clone clients A and B on the switch simultaneously, Client A writes:
---------- udpreceiver for /dev/hda2 at 10.90.0.172 on eth0 received message cap=00000019 connected as #0 to 10.90.0.167 listening to multicast on 234.90.0.167 ---------- and then writes nothing else. Client B is similar.
The server writes numerous lines like this: ------------- Timeout notAnswered=[1] notReady[1] nrAns=0 nrRead=0 nrPart=1 avg=65625 -------------
After what seems like a couple of minutes, the clients drop off and then the server stops.
We are using a class B subnet which initially gave me problems, but after specifying the broadcast address on the DHCP server I can confirm the clients and server are all using a bcast address of 10.90.255.255
We are using a 3Com 4226T switch and in the list archives I see several references to problems with 3Com switches and IGMP. I have disabled IGMP querying and snooping, and disabled broadcast storm control. Flow control can be specified per port - so for the 3 ports that these machines are connected to, I've disabled flow control, disabled auto-negotiate, and set to 100Mbps full duplex. (There are other active ports in use on the switch and I've left those on auto-negotiate with flow control.)
Does anyone have some advice?
Thanks for your time, Andrew Cameron Systems Administrator Vermont Legal Aid, Inc.
On Wednesday 18 May 2005 22:56, Andrew Cameron wrote:
Hello,
Here is my scenario. Clients A and B can succesfully be cloned from a server running udp-sender when connected together via a hub. Either one can also be successfully cloned as the only client to the server when connected on the switch (as I understand it, this scenario is actually unicast, not multicast).
Yes, that's indeed what happens: if there is a single receiver, it uses unicast.
When attemping to clone clients A and B on the switch simultaneously, Client A writes:
[...] [...]
Does anyone have some advice?
No advice about the switch, unfortunately, but there is a flag for udp-sender to work around these kinds of problems: --broadcast
On the command line, you call it as follows
udp-sender --broadcast image
For the bootable image, you enter --broadcast into the "Additional parameters" dialog box (which appears almost at the end, just after the choice of disk, and before the choice of compression)
Thanks for your time, Andrew Cameron Systems Administrator Vermont Legal Aid, Inc.
Regards,
Alain